Crate Digging: Fotheringay by Fotheringay


Since inception in 2003, a self-imposed rule of my Album of the Month is that it must be new. Looking forward is fundamental to music, its lifeblood. That will continue; however, since I have re-engaged with vinyl, rediscovered that vital connection with the music I adore and now idle away weekends in second-hand record shops, I am going to highlight an album or perhaps single that I have acquired in the previous month that might pique the interest of Vinous readers. I might re-evaluate a well-known favourite or it could be obscure. The only rule is quality. What you will certainly glean is the eclecticism of my musical tastes.

This month we go back to the early Seventies and English folk. I fell in love with Fairport Convention, Bert Jansch, Pentangle and of course, Nick Drake, in my late twenties. At the centre of this scene is one of England’s finest female singers, Sandy Denny. She formed Fotheringay, named after the castle where Mary Queen of Scots was imprisoned, after leaving Fairport Convention, and was joined by band-mates Trevor Conway, Gerry Conway, Jerry Donahue and Pat Donaldson. Their album is a mixture of original and covers: a rollicking version of Dylan’s “Too Much of Nothing” and Gordon Lightfoot’s “The Way I Feel”. Both are excellent. However, it is Denny’s own compositions that elevate this into one of greatest and I would argue, overlooked folk albums of the era. Her vocals never sounded so plaintive and ethereal. It is difficult to put my finger on exactly why, but Denny’s voice, her timbre and inflection, makes her sound as if she is singing from centuries back in history, like medieval princess pining from her castle tower to a lost prince. Listen to “The Sea”, “The Pond and the Stream” or the spectral “Winter Winds” and lose yourself. Legendary producer, Joe Boyd, imbues all the arrangements with immense clarity so that the listener can appreciate the outstanding musicianship and, not unlike Nick Drake, gives it a sense of timelessness.

The album was a moderate success but it proved to be their solitary release, Denny persuaded by Boyd to embark upon a solo career. She had her own demons, deep-set insecurity and an alcohol problem, which led to her untimely passing in 1978 (spookily, in the same hospital where I underwent my own surgery.) I already owned the CD, but hankered for an original vinyl copy printed the famous pink Island “i” label. I chanced upon one whilst crate-digging at the Guildford record fair. At £70.00 it was not cheap, but the record was in almost mint condition and can abide just a bit of wear and tear on the glorious gatefold sleeve. If you are normal and do not need an original copy, Fotheringay was reissued on vinyl a couple of years back, or you can stream the album on Spotify, Tidal etc.

The brief lifespan of the group means that there is not much to find, however that is partially compensated by this stunning live set on German TV program “Beat Club”.

Wine Recommendation

I should nominate a bottle from the same year as the record’s release. So I recommend a bottle of 1970 Pichon-Lalande, one of the better wines from the estate in that era and cheaper than Latour.